YouTube's Copyright System Isn't Broken. The World's Is.

12 994
167
 
No copyright infringement intended. | Watch Money, my new Nebula Original series, with a 30-day free trial of CuriosityStream: curiositystream.com/tomscott
WRITTEN BY: Tom Scott
SCRIPT ASSISTANT: Andrea Marks
CAMERA: Jamie Drew
CAMERA: Joe Stone
AUDIO MIX: Graham Haerther
EDITOR: Isla McTear
CAPTIONS: Caption+
WITH THANKS TO:
1901 Arts Club
The Camera Museum, Soho
Evan Edinger
The Lexi Cinema, Kensal Green
Mandy Celine
Oliver Thorn
Tim Bunn
LEGAL CAMEOS:
Leonard French ismind.info
Devin Stone ismind.info
QUASI-LEGAL CAMEO:
Jay Foreman ismind.info
MINECRAFT SEQUENCE:
Joel "Smallishbeans" ismind.info
MUSIC
Epidemic Sound
Canon in D solo piano recording courtesy of ProstoRecords and Envato Market
Canon in D rock recording courtesy of Kora3000 and Envato Market
STOCK PHOTOGRAPHY
Images used under license from shutterstock.com
PRODUCER
Reb Day
© Pad 26 Limited MMXX

tomscott.com
twitter.com/tomscott
instagram.com/tomscottgo
Lengd: 42:29

Ummæli

Tom Scott
Tom Scott - 19 dögum síðan
Yep, 42 minutes of video. This was a big project. Plus: I've got an all-new five-part original series called Money over on Nebula, which you can watch as a bundle with CuriosityStream! https://curiositystream.com/tomscott
Ventus Pri
Ventus Pri - 7 klukkustundum síðan
IT was a good VIDEO
The GoldenKeyboard
The GoldenKeyboard - 15 klukkustundum síðan
It would've been so ironic if this video got copyright claimed XD
A\T Gordon
A\T Gordon - Degi Síðan síðan
Thank you. That was a load of useful information and awesome opinions. But shouldn't you have been censoring the license plates of the cars?
Joseph Catrambone
Joseph Catrambone - 2 dögum síðan
It's okay. This is your best video.
André Teixeira
André Teixeira - 2 dögum síðan
@Hecking Bamboozled Too bad you know nothing about it and let your ideology blind the reason. If you are not afraid of changing or mind or noticing your way of thinking might be wrong, do a short reasearch about Index of Economic Freedom and Economic Freedom of the World.
Osvald Lindholm
Osvald Lindholm - 8 klukkustundum síðan
I hope you answer to this, because I'm genuinely at most curious.
If you're not allowed to show album art without criticising it. How is the copyright regarding the Pikachu toy in the background at 28:12 ?. Doesn't that infringe on copyright? And if it does, does that mean all things (or most) utilities/furnitures/items could be claimed as a designed item and thus have copyright as well? Then one would not be legally allowed to show a video recording of their home.
I hope I am wrong, because otherwise everyone is f*cked.
Bapple
Bapple - 8 klukkustundum síðan
mumbo jumbo!!!
zijuiy wttuy
zijuiy wttuy - 8 klukkustundum síðan
just translated as lawful bribing). I hope that change will come if not for us then for our children.
Jon Knight
Jon Knight - 8 klukkustundum síðan
I want a fact/opinion switch in our office meeting rooms! :-)
zijuiy wttuy
zijuiy wttuy - 8 klukkustundum síðan
I have seen many of your video's this is by far the best one. You explain so well how the world deals with this problem now. Sadly the power of change is mostly in the hands
nobody5050
nobody5050 - 9 klukkustundum síðan
I have gotten so many videos taken down by Nintendo. I don’t earn any money off of their game, I’m not stealing any revenue. Especially on games that are no longer being sold.
fuzzy pilot
fuzzy pilot - 9 klukkustundum síðan
Billion dollar company: makes a song
Kid on YouTube: uses a song that made millons
Billon dollar company: so you have chosen death
Commandtechno
Commandtechno - 9 klukkustundum síðan
Are quotes copyrightable?
Michael Brookman
Michael Brookman - 9 klukkustundum síðan
this was awesome viewing, thanks.
René Verberkt
René Verberkt - 9 klukkustundum síðan
Imagine if the wheel had been copyrighted, we'd all still be in the legal stoneage.
Elliott Bork
Elliott Bork - 9 klukkustundum síðan
Stock photos were great you should make a whole series about them
reaktor55
reaktor55 - 10 klukkustundum síðan
is there a copyright infringement version of no homo?
Anthony Lipke
Anthony Lipke - 10 klukkustundum síðan
The lawyers and the big companies seem top have authored copy right law with little regard for people and culture.
The original principal in the constitution was to encourage arts and sciences. I think its practice is more akin to its English origins in censorship and rent seeking.
Austin Bosma
Austin Bosma - 10 klukkustundum síðan
Dangerously funny is saving me $400 buy play animal crossing
ScalyLayde
ScalyLayde - 10 klukkustundum síðan
love the legal eagle cameo.
Also, I realize neither of us are lawyers, but about streaming video games and it's impact on sales- there is an argument to make that it's beneficial. Someone might be more likely to shell out $60-$80 for a game if they know what they're getting. This is the reason some publishers allow free demos of their games in order to discourage piracy, which is logic tells me is more detrimental than youtube videos or free demos are.
Cara Carissima
Cara Carissima - 10 klukkustundum síðan
this is very useful
01sanguinius
01sanguinius - 11 klukkustundum síðan
the other problem with jukin was that they weren't always informing the owner of the rights and keeping the money for themselves.
Danielle White
Danielle White - 11 klukkustundum síðan
In the past, a lot of those silly videos made by kids were on VHS or audio cassette tapes, providing for them to escape detection.
I used to be on the board of a tech non-profit in the US. We got one through some sort of licensing clearing-house about a web comic that was used on the site. It took us a long time to locate it in a PDF of a presentation that someone put online at some prior point (none of the board members dealing with the complaint had been involved when it was.) Pay it and move on was the answer.
Gerd L. Plüü
Gerd L. Plüü - 11 klukkustundum síðan
The world is indeed broken, but that doesn't automatically make Youtubes content ID system not broken.
Felix FTV
Felix FTV - 11 klukkustundum síðan
17:15 none is speaking about the diamonds picked up with a stone pickaxe?????
Leon Straathof
Leon Straathof - 11 klukkustundum síðan
I have seen many of your video's this is by far the best one. You explain so well how the world deals with this problem now. Sadly the power of change is mostly in the hands of corporations who don't want any of these changes. Like always in these types of conflict only can be solved by politicians who do care less about lobbying (which in my book is just translated as lawful bribing). I hope that change will come if not for us then for our children.
Paul Hembree
Paul Hembree - 12 klukkustundum síðan
I think patents and copyright laws should last 100 years.
This is gonna sound stupid, but
This is gonna sound stupid, but - 12 klukkustundum síðan
GIF is pronounced with a hard G in every sense. Graphical is not pronounced Jiraffical.
Kring
Kring - 12 klukkustundum síðan
Perhaps creators should not have a right to decide how their works are used. My opinion about copyright law is that it should entirely disappear.
The Dancing Geese
The Dancing Geese - 12 klukkustundum síðan
Any body else see the Jay formen cameo?
James Ducas
James Ducas - 12 klukkustundum síðan
Excellent video as always, Tom.
Nomecla Absorber
Nomecla Absorber - 14 klukkustundum síðan
Tom you do not have the right to call hide the pain Harold part of the “nerdy underside of YouTube” when you make education videos
drosera
drosera - 14 klukkustundum síðan
i think more people need to think less about legality and more about morality.
drosera
drosera - 14 klukkustundum síðan
ayyy i commented like halfway, glad to see you mentioned this
hopin8krzys
hopin8krzys - 14 klukkustundum síðan
What a filthy commie propaganda
What next, workers rigths? Absurd
Not Me
Not Me - 15 klukkustundum síðan
No one gonna talk about that small peepee car at 32:15 using his lights wrong? Or do I have the brain capacity of canned tuna? Maybe a combination of both
Tim Hawthorn
Tim Hawthorn - 15 klukkustundum síðan
Thanks for doing this. As you're one of the people who is inspiring me to start making videos, this is probably my biggest worry. I was considering a 'publish and be damned' approach, but you've caused me to revise that. My gut feeling is to stick with content I have created myself or that which is open sourced / creative commons. The tricky bit is finding images of archaeological artefacts which I can't just go and take myself
The GoldenKeyboard
The GoldenKeyboard - 15 klukkustundum síðan
Still waiting for episode 2 of tom reacts
Hayabusa Ryuu
Hayabusa Ryuu - 15 klukkustundum síðan
Legal vampire spoted!
The GoldenKeyboard
The GoldenKeyboard - 15 klukkustundum síðan
I like a good spote
SwordBreaker925
SwordBreaker925 - 16 klukkustundum síðan
Video game streaming is absolutely fair use. If the law says that my own gameplay is copyright infringement, then the law is wrong.
Everyone knows the copyright system is broken and designed to monetarily benefit big corporations, but there's nothing we can do because those companies can bribe politicians into not changing those laws.
Hade Chxn
Hade Chxn - 16 klukkustundum síðan
Dont know why but I genuinely expected a 42min single take.
RK Beck
RK Beck - 16 klukkustundum síðan
Big ups to Legal Eagle and his cameo here, good sense of humour.
Exxag
Exxag - 16 klukkustundum síðan
"AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH"

I kinda expected Tom to scream AHHH back
Martin Piggins
Martin Piggins - 17 klukkustundum síðan
Haha, it good you can laugh at yourself, thanks for the outtakes 👍🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿
nixeh32
nixeh32 - 17 klukkustundum síðan
Everyone should watch this, you're a legend Tom!
First Name Last Name
First Name Last Name - 17 klukkustundum síðan
Jay screaming in his cameo is very on brand
Bennett Snyder
Bennett Snyder - 18 klukkustundum síðan
In general this video gets a lot of things right but I do think that it lets YouTube off the hook in one major way: they should be going to bat for their creators to lobby for a better system. They're the only institution in this debate that has the clout to stand up to legacy rights-holders, and there should be pressure on them to use their resources to protect the people who make the content they make money off of.
Balter
Balter - 19 klukkustundum síðan
Showing Wendover Production's face hey?
Sheng Han
Sheng Han - 19 klukkustundum síðan
Quite a in depth analysis.
F Torrado
F Torrado - 19 klukkustundum síðan
Please stop, there's some interesting valid points, but your criticism is actually just perpetuating some of the problems with copyright. The whole "winner takes it all" mentality is wrong! Less copyright safeguards is the only way to go
Timmy P
Timmy P - 20 klukkustundum síðan
Having LegalEagle be a vampire was gold
Egon
Egon - 20 klukkustundum síðan
You are stupid and missing the point.
YouTube's Copyright System IS Broken, and is broken because it does not give creators proper tools to counter false claims.
Not the mention:
the idea that during dispute money from revenue are going to party claiming the video (instead of being withhold by YT until claim gets resolved) it's extremely stupid.
**
** - 21 klukkustund síðan
Outstanding analysis. Thanks Tom!
Gabby Edgar
Gabby Edgar - 21 klukkustund síðan
the reason kids think thats isnt entirely bc theyre entitled i think theyre confusing copyright law with the rules theyve been told in school for what is and isnt plagiarism
ORGdotEDU films
ORGdotEDU films - 22 klukkustundum síðan
I never realized how much YouTube's Content ID system saves me from copyright strikes and lawsuits. Genuinely scary. I've used songs in videos that, although not monetized, infringed on copyright law, all without knowing so. Really puts the false claims into perspective... huh...
ReverendTed
ReverendTed - 23 klukkustundum síðan
What I don't like is that copyright, or more specifically YouTube's contractual implementation of it, seems to be an "all or nothing" proposition. You can't split revenue (manually or automatically) even if the claimed portion of your work is a fraction of the total. (Either in that the claimed portion is a fraction of YOUR work or that you've only used a fraction of THEIR work.)
Nick Cunningham
Nick Cunningham - Degi Síðan síðan
I'm watching this right after finding out that Warner Bros copyrighted MeatCanyon's Wabbit Season. Btw, it's now officially canon that Bugs Bunny is a rapist
Jacob Wh Khu
Jacob Wh Khu - Degi Síðan síðan
Copyright infringement is more serious than war crimes nowadays
Snow Man
Snow Man - Degi Síðan síðan
What about musicians who have been getting their music copyright-claimed even though they composed and performed the pieces themselves? I'd say as long as that is allowed/happening, the copyright system on youtube is indeed broken, Tom
midivilplanet
midivilplanet - Degi Síðan síðan
*Bloopers follow this sponsored advertising*
Alright you got me
Snow Man
Snow Man - Degi Síðan síðan
part of me wants to see this copyright striked to prove tom that youtube's system is actually broken
Richard Gray
Richard Gray - Degi Síðan síðan
Great. Comprehensive. Understandable. WOW!
0MindSwept0
0MindSwept0 - Degi Síðan síðan
aaAAAAAAAA
MyriadIsSynonymousWithNumerous
MyriadIsSynonymousWithNumerous - Degi Síðan síðan
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR CORRECTING YOUR PRONUNCIATION OF DISPUTES
t. English teacher
Fancypants McVomitshirt
Fancypants McVomitshirt - Degi Síðan síðan
I think 50 years is a bit harsh. Some artists are only "discovered" long after they publish. I think 70 is fair, from the date of publication or creation. Extending copyright long after the artists death is stupid though.
Michal Walks
Michal Walks - Degi Síðan síðan
Every word in your monologue has been used, one time or another, as lyrics in a song. How would you feel if you got a copyright strike and your account deleted with years of work gone because of this? Well, the same is going on with false claims. I have to tune out as this is an advertisement.
zachos 2000
zachos 2000 - Degi Síðan síðan
"there is an enormous distance between what the law says and what the world is doing", this is a seriously good quote, might be completely obvious to some but it's so very true, definitely one of my top 10 or top 15 favorite quotes I think... Hmm actually are quotes also copyrighted?? Can I quote people freely?
bill19282
bill19282 - Degi Síðan síðan
i think it should be upon death instead of 50 years !!
Barry Soetoro
Barry Soetoro - Degi Síðan síðan
Most of the tension in my exp is where one youtuber will strike another youtuber because they are saying things they dont like. Or at least thats what people mean by its broken.
Kaedenn
Kaedenn - Degi Síðan síðan
Very controversial topic with 98.47% positive reactions (as of this comment)? Something tells me this is yet another of your absolutely incredible works. How do YOU feel, Tom, about people sharing this video and using parts of it to educate each other?
Barry Soetoro
Barry Soetoro - Degi Síðan síðan
I have the true wand that makes lawyers go away....Its called no assets, no bank account & tons of debt. Poof lawyers be gone. Sure Ill show up the the trial act a fool & laugh when they hit me with a judgement.
Dondlo
Dondlo - Degi Síðan síðan
Plot Twist:this video was copyrighted
namejeffVEVO
namejeffVEVO - Degi Síðan síðan
its pronounced jif
Cassie
Cassie - Degi Síðan síðan
Me: stops the video at 4 minutes looks at the duration 42 MINUTES OF VIDEO? goes to the comments Tom: Yup, 42 minutes of video. Also me: HOW DID YOU KNOW?
TheJadedRabbit
TheJadedRabbit - Degi Síðan síðan
hold on, I have questions about why those two making cookies were wearing gas masks? I mean I have plenty of questions about stock photo's in general but that one is up there as my top WTF one and makes me ask but why?
Cassie
Cassie - Degi Síðan síðan
12:00 bojler eladó
Veggiemite Games
Veggiemite Games - Degi Síðan síðan
As a tiny youtube channel that constantly worries about copyright and "fair use" this was very enlightening.
Joe Prado
Joe Prado - Degi Síðan síðan
Can’t wait for a company to cryogenically freeze a musician so they can have infinite copyright.
Brian Duncan
Brian Duncan - Degi Síðan síðan
I always enjoy listening to one of the most intelligent people on this platform.

Thank you.
Steven Zhu
Steven Zhu - Degi Síðan síðan
Is it just me, but his body looks thin compare to his head and arms.
default default
default default - Degi Síðan síðan
this video is wow
jangoofy
jangoofy - Degi Síðan síðan
29:58 - hold up, there are still telephone booths in the UK ? or did the Tardis finally get a new skin ?
Rab Townsend
Rab Townsend - Degi Síðan síðan
The most controversial position in this video is that there is a difference between "DISputes" and "disPUTES" besides emphasis.
RepeatYourself
RepeatYourself - Degi Síðan síðan
Legal Eagle!
Cringe Overload!!
Cringe Overload!! - Degi Síðan síðan
How about trailers and little bits of video showing of a piece of work to get people to buy or subscribe? would it be okay to post that for yourself? i mean you would just be promoting the content?
Marty Hopkirk
Marty Hopkirk - Degi Síðan síðan
Always enjoy your videos Tom, & this one has not failed to deliver again. Well put.
Arthur Guseynov
Arthur Guseynov - Degi Síðan síðan
Long video init?
霊Radoncombe
霊Radoncombe - Degi Síðan síðan
Scott Rants.
Áfram